The Anglo-Saxons
Very little is known about what happened to the defences in the Anglo-Saxon period. The early Anglo-Saxons were not accustomed to build in stone, and did not have the expertise to repair the natural decay of the stone and mortar. There is some archaeological evidence that suggests that the fortress defences were maintained and strengthened by successive additions to the earthen rampart, which eventually, in some places, covered over the remains of the Roman stone wall.
The lines of four principal roads of the fortress – including High Petergate, Low Petergate, Stonegate and Chapter House Street – survive to the present day. This suggests that the four main Roman gateways also existed and that the Roman walls continued to block other routes.
Literary evidence from the period is scarce and unreliable. Alcuin of York, who wrote in the 8th century, starts his poem ‘On the Bishops, Kings and Saints of York’ with the lines: ‘York, with its high walls, and lofty towers, was first built by Roman hands’; but when he talks of the ‘lofty walls of the city’, it isn’t clear whether this refers to new, Anglo-Saxon earth ramparts or to the remains of the Roman walls. A century later Asser, a Welsh monk living in southern England wrote a ‘Life of King Alfred’, in which he says that ‘the city did not possess strong and well-built walls’ when describing York’s capture by the Vikings; but did he know that for a fact, or did he just make it up?

There would certainly have been little or no reason for the Anglo-Saxon inhabitants of York to demolish the walls, but little is known of how they were maintained. The best, but limited, archaeological evidence comes from excavation on the line the former Roman fortress defences south-west of the Anglian Tower. This has produced evidence of several phases of repair which apparently date to the 7th–9th centuries, before the Viking attack on York in 866. These repairs heightened the earth ramparts, which were capped with a timber stockade. Eventually, in some places the enlarged ramparts covered over the remains of the Roman wall.